What Pest Control Buyers Mean When They Talk About Customer Retention
Buyers use terms like retention rate, average tenure, and churn constantly — but what do they actually mean for your route's value? Here's exactly what buyers are measuring and why it matters.
Walk into any conversation with a serious pest control route buyer and within five minutes they'll ask about your retention. If you answer with something vague — "most customers stay pretty long" or "I don't have a lot of cancellations" — the conversation shifts in ways that hurt you. Buyers who can't verify retention assumptions fill in the gap with conservative estimates. And conservative estimates mean a lower offer.
Understanding exactly what retention means — and knowing your own number — is one of the simplest ways to protect your asking price.
Three Terms, One Concept
Annual retention rate
The percentage of your customers at the start of a year who are still customers at the end of that year. If you started January with 100 customers and ended December with 88 of those same customers (ignoring new customers added), your annual retention rate is 88%. This is the primary metric buyers use to model post-acquisition churn risk.
Average customer tenure
The average length of time your current customers have been with you. This is a different cut of the same idea. A high average tenure (3+ years) tells a buyer that your customer relationships are durable and that the revenue is "sticky." A low average tenure (under 1 year) suggests high churn or a route that's mostly new customers — both of which carry risk.
Churn rate
The inverse of retention — the percentage of customers you lose in a given period. A 15% annual churn rate means you lose roughly 1 in 7 customers per year. For a buyer acquiring a $5,000/month MRR route, a 15% churn rate means $750/month of that revenue could be gone in year one before they acquire a single new customer.
The Retention Benchmarks Buyers Use
| Rate | Relative Strength | Buyer Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Below 75% | Weak | Heavy discount |
| 75% – 84% | Average | Below average |
| 85% – 90% | Strong | Strong |
| Above 90% | Premium | Premium multiple |
Routes with retention below 75% will face significant price pressure. Buyers know that a meaningful portion of the revenue they're acquiring will cancel in the first 12 months. They model that risk directly into their offer — often deducting the expected year-one churn from the purchase price calculation entirely.
The First-Year Churn Problem
Route transfers are a high-churn event. Even on a well-run route, some customers will cancel when they hear service is changing hands. Buyers know this and price it in. Your job as a seller is to show that your retention has been consistently high — which gives buyers confidence that the transition churn will be minimal.
How to Improve Your Retention Before You Sell
Fix the 90-day drop-off
The majority of pest control churn happens in the first 90 days after service. A customer who makes it to their third quarterly service is very likely to stay. Focus your retention effort on new customers: a check-in call at 30 days, an automated SMS reminder before the second service, and a follow-up after the second visit asking if they're satisfied. This alone can meaningfully move your retention rate.
Document your data so buyers can verify it
A self-reported retention rate of 90% carries much less weight than a CRM showing 24 months of service records, customer tenure history, and cancellation notes. Buyers pay for certainty. If you can show the data — not just state the number — your retention claim becomes a selling point rather than a claim to be discounted.
Know Your Retention Rate Before You List
PestPro CRM tracks customer tenure and service history automatically. Verified retention data commands higher multiples.
Ready to get organized?
PestPro CRM helps pest control operators manage customers, schedule services, and track recurring revenue.
Start Free Trial
The PestPro Team creates resources to help pest control business owners succeed.Our CRM is built specifically for solo operators and small teams.